The Story of Cole Younger, by
Himself
Being an Autobiography of the Missouri Guerrilla Captain
and
Outlaw, his Capture and Prison Life, and the Only
Authentic
Account of the Northfield Raid Ever
Published
By Cole Younger
21. The Truth about John
Younger John, my
brother, was fourteen when the war closed and Bob under twelve. One day in
January, 1866, John, Bob and my mother drove into Independence to mill,
and to do other errands in town, one of which was to get one of my pistols
fixed. A young fellow named Gillcreas, who had served in
the militia and was several years John's senior, hit the boy with a piece
of mackerel, and warm words ensued. “Why don't you shoot him?” shouted Bob from the wagon. John
told the fellow if Cole were there he would not dare do that, and
Gillcreas said Cole should be in prison, and all Quantrell's men with him.
Gillcreas went away, but returned to the attack, this time armed with a
heavy slungshot. In the meantime John had gotten the pistol which had been
in the wagon. Gillcreas
came up to resume the fight and John shot him dead.
The
slungshot was found with the thong twined about Gillcreas' wrist. The
coroner's jury acquitted John, and there were many people in Independence
who felt that he had done just right. When I went to Louisiana in 1868
John went with me, afterward accompanying me to Texas. Clerking in a store
in Dallas, he became associated with some young fellows of reckless habits
and drank somewhat. One day,
while they were all in a gay mood, John shot the pipe out of the mouth of
a fellow named Russell. Russell jumped up and ran out of the
room. “Don't kill him,” shouted the crowd in ridicule, and John fired
several random shots to keep up the scare. Russell swore out a warrant for
John's arrest, and next morning, Jan. 17, 1871, Capt. S. W. Nichols, the
sheriff, and John McMahon came up to the house to arrest him. John made no
resistance and invited the officers to breakfast, but they declined and
went back down town. Thompson McDaniels called John's attention to the
fact that a guard had been stationed over his horses, and they walked down
town together. Tom and John drank some whisky, and while they were waiting
Nichols and his party had taken on some
too. “What did you put a guard over my horses for?” asked John, when
he entered the room where Nichols was. “I did not put any guard over your horses,” replied
Nichols. “You're a——liar,” continued John, “I saw them there
myself.” At this
another Russell, a brother of the one whose pipe had been shot out of his
mouth, opened fire on John and wounded him in the arm. Thomp. McDaniels
shot Capt. Nichols, and in the melee McMahon was shot, as far as I have
ever been able to learn, by my brother. John and
McDaniels went out, took the officers' horses and rode to
Missouri. It developed after the shooting that the same Russell who had
opened fire on John had placed the guard over the horses, and that Capt.
Nichols had not known of it. I was away
in Louisiana at the time, but on my return several attorneys offered to
defend John if he would return for trial, but after a visit at the home of
our uncle in California he returned to Missouri in the winter of 1873 and
1874, just in time to be suspected of the train robbery at Gad's Hill, on
the Iron Mountain road. John and
Jim were visiting at the home of our friend, Theodoric Snuffer, at Monegaw
Springs, St. Clair county. Man-hunters had sought us there on a previous
occasion when we were all four there. We had come upon the party of 15
suddenly, and I covered them with a shot-gun, demanded their
surrender, and explaining that we had not robbed anybody, and wanted to be
treated as decent citizens, approached by officers of the law in the
regular manner if we were accused, restored their arms to them, and they
went back to Osceola. March 11,
1874, J. W. Whicher, a Pinkerton detective from Chicago, who had been sent
out to arrest Frank and Jesse James at Kearney, was found dead in the road
near Independence, and W. J. Allen, otherwise known as Capt. Lull, a St.
Louis plain-clothes cop who passed by the name of Wright, and an Osceola
boy named Ed. Daniels, who was a deputy sheriff with an ambition to
shine as a sleuth, rode out to find Jim and Bob at the
Springs. The boys,
advised of their coming by a negro servant, sought to convince them, as we
had the earlier posse, that they could not have had anything to do with
the affair at Gad's Hill. But Allen, remembering the recent fate of
Whicher, drew his pistol and shot John in the neck. John returned the fire
and killed Daniels and took after Allen. Side by side the horses galloped, John firing
at the detective till he fell from the saddle mortally wounded. John
turned to ride back to where Jim was, when he toppled from his saddle and
was dead in a few minutes. The St.
Louis detective had fled at the first fire, and lived to tell graphic
stories of how it all happened, although he was really too busy getting
out to know anything about it. 22. Amnesty Bill Fails The killing
of Lull, Daniels and Whicher within a single week was undoubtedly
exasperating to the head of the Pinkerton agency, and had he not been
personally embittered thereby he probably would not have avenged it so
terribly. In the next
January, 1875, a posse of Pinkerton men and others, guided by Daniel H.
Asker, a neighbor of the James boys, proceeded to their home near Kearney
and threw a bomb into the house where the family was seated. An
eight-year-old half-brother of Frank and Jesse was killed, their mother,
Mrs. Samuels, had one arm torn off, and other members of the family were
more or less injured. But Frank and Jesse were not taken.
There had
been a feeling among many people in the state even before that these
detectives were unjustly pursuing some of the Confederate soldiers, and I
have been told since that Gov. Silas Woodson was on the eve of interfering
with Pinkerton's men when news came that two of them had been killed in
an encounter with John and Jim
Younger. At any rate
the death of the innocent little Samuels boy made still more pronounced
this feeling against the operations of the detectives, and in favor of the
members of the Confederate army who had been outlawed by Fremont, Halleck,
Ewing and the Drake constitution, ungenerously, to say the least.
This feeling found definite expression shortly after the raid
on the Samuels home in the introduction of a bill in the Missouri
legislature offering amnesty to the Younger and James brothers by name,
and others who had been outlawed with them by proclamation, from all their
acts during the war, and promising them a fair trial on any charge against
them arising after the war. The bill
was introduced in the house by the late General Jeff Jones, of Callaway
county, where my brothers and myself had many friends, and was, in the
main, as follows: “Whereas, by the 4th section of the 11th article of the Constitutionof Missouri, all persons in the military service of the United States or who acted under the authority thereof in this state, are relieved from all civil liability and all criminal punishment for all acts done by them since the 1st day of January, A.D. 1861; and,” “Whereas, By the 12th section of the said 11th article of said
constitution provision is made by which, under certain circumstances, may
be seized, transported to, indicted, tried and punished in distant
counties, any confederate under ban of despotic displeasure, thereby
contravening the Constitution of the United States and every principle of enlightened humanity;
and,” “Whereas, Such discrimination evinces a want of manly
generosity and statesmanship on the part of the party imposing,
and of courage and manhood on the part of the party
submitting tamely thereto; and,” “Whereas, Under the outlawry pronounced against Jesse W. James,
Frank James, Coleman Younger, James Younger and others, who gallantly
periled their lives and their all in defense of their principles, they are
of necessity made desperate, driven as they are from the fields of honest
industry, from their friends, their families, their homes and their
country, they can know no law but the law of self-preservation, nor can
have no respect for and feel no allegiance to a government which forces
them to the very acts it professes to deprecate, and then offers a bounty
for their apprehension, and arms foreign mercenaries with power to capture
and kill them; and,” “Whereas, Believing these men too brave to be mean, too
generous to be revengeful, and too gallant and honorable to betray a
friend or break a promise; and believing further that most, if not all of
the offenses with which they are charged have been committed by others,
and perhaps by those pretending to hunt them, or by their confederates; that their names are and
have been used to divert suspicion from and thereby relieve the actual
perpetrators; that the return of these men to their homes and friends
would have the effect of greatly lessening crime in our state by turning
public attention to the real criminals,
and that common justice, sound policy and true statesmanship alike
demand that amnesty should be extended to all alike of both parties for
all acts done or charged to have been done during the war; therefore, be
it” That the Governor of the state be, and he is
hereby requested to issue his proclamation notifying the said Jesse W.
James, Frank James, Coleman Younger, and James Younger and others, that
full and complete amnesty and pardon will be granted them for all acts
charged or committed by them during the late civil war, and inviting them
peacefully to return to their respective homes in this state and there
quietly to remain, submitting themselves to such proceedings as may be
instituted against them by the courts for all offenses charged to have
been committed since said war, promising and guaranteeing to each of
them full protection and a fair trial therein, and that full protection
shall be given them from the time of their entrance into the state and his
notice thereof under said proclamation and
invitation.” It was
approved by Attorney-General Hockaday, favorably reported by a majority of
the committee on criminal jurisprudence, but while it was pending Farmer
Askew, who had piloted the detectives in their raid on the Samuels
residence, was called to his door at night and shot and killed by unknown
parties. The bill was beaten, Democrats and Confederate soldiers voting
against it. For myself,
the only charge against me was the unwarranted one of the killing of young
Judy during the war, but the failure of the bill left us still under the
ban of outlawry. 23. Belle Starr One of the
richest mines for the romancers who have pretended to write the story of
my life was the fertile imagination of Belle Starr, who is now dead, peace
to her ashes. These fairy
tales have told how the “Cherokee maiden fell in love with the dashing
captain.” As a matter of fact, Belle Starr was not a Cherokee. Her father
was John Shirley, who during the war had a hotel at Carthage, Mo. In the
spring of 1864, while I was in Texas, I visited her father, who had a farm
near Syene, in Dallas county. Belle Shirley was then 14, and there were two
or three brothers smaller. The next
time I saw Belle Shirley was in 1868, in Bates county, Mo. She was then
the wife of Jim Reed, who had been in my company during the war, and she
was at the home of his mother. This was about three months before the
birth of her eldest child, Pearl Reed, afterward known as Pearl Starr,
after Belle's second husband. In 1871,
while I was herding cattle in Texas, Jim Reed and his wife, with their two
children, came back to her people. Reed had run afoul of the Federal
authorities for passing counterfeit money at Los Angeles and had skipped
between two days. Belle told her people she was tired roaming the country
over and wanted to settle down at Syene. Mrs. Shirley wanted to give them
part the farm, and knowing my influence with the father, asked me to
intercede in behalf of the young folks. I did, and he set them up on the
farm, and I cut out a lot of the calves from one of my two herds and left
with them. That day
Belle Reed told me her troubles, and that night “Aunt Suse,” our family
servant, warned me. “Belle's sure in
love with you, Cap'n Cole,” she
explained. “You better be careful.” With that
hint I thereafter evaded the wife of my former comrade in arms. Reed was
killed a few years later after the robbery of the stage near San Antonio,
and Belle married again, this time Tom Starr or Sam
Starr. Later she
came to Missouri and traveled under the name of Younger, boasted of an
intimate acquaintance with me, served time in state prison, and at this
time declared that she was my wife, and that the girl Pearl was our
child. At this
time I had no knowledge of any one named Belle Starr, and I was at a loss
as to her identity until the late Lillian Lewis, the actress, who was
related to some very good friends of our family, inquired about her on one
of her tours through the southwest. Visiting me in prison, she told me
that Belle Starr was the daughter of John Shirley, and then for the first
time had I any clue as to her identity. Her story
was a fabrication, inspired undoubtedly by the notoriety it would give her
through the Cherokee nation, where the name of Younger was widely known,
whether fortunately or unfortunately. 24. “Captain Dykes” The winter
that the amnesty bill was before the Missouri legislature I spent in
Florida, with the exception of a short trip to Cuba. I was the greater
part of the time at Lake City. I sent Bob to school at William and Mary
college, but the same proud spirit that caused him to leave Dallas in 1872
impelled him to leave college when his fellow students began to connect
his uncommon name with that of the notorious Missouri outlaw, Cole
Younger. He rejoined
me in Florida. I was “Mr. Dykes,” a sojourner from the north, and while I
carried a pair of pistols in my belt to guard against the appearance of
any of Judy's ilk, the people of Lake City never knew it until one day
when the village was threatened with a race
riot. A lot of
the blacks there had been members of a negro regiment and all had arms. My
barber was of a different school of darkies, and the Lake City blacks
determined to run him out of town. He told me of the plan, and I did not
take much stock in it until one morning when I was being shaved I heard
the plotters, over a bottle of whisky in an adjoining room, declaring what they were
going to do. Soon after I left the shop I heard a pistol shot, and turning
around to see what was the matter, I saw my barber running toward me,
while the other darkies were scattering to their homes for their guns. I
walked up the street a little distance with the barber, when some one called to me, and I saw that the
lieutenant of this old company had us covered by his gun. I ran up to him
and planting my pistol between his eyes, commanded him to drop the gun,
which the barber got in a jiffy. The pistol shot in the shop had alarmed
the merchants, each of whom kept a gun in his store, and thereafter as the blacks came to the
rallying place in the public square with their guns we disarmed them
quicker than it takes to tell it, and they were locked up to cool
off. After that
I was dubbed “Capt.” Dykes, by unanimous consent, and had to be more
careful than before lest the military title should attract to me the
attention of some curious investigator who would have overlooked entirely
“Mr. Dykes.” The
disguised outlaw became during the remainder of his residence a leading
and respected citizen. When the election was held it was “Capt. Dykes” who
was called upon to preserve order at the polls, he, of course, having no
interest as between the rival candidates, and with pistols in easy reach
he maintained perfect order during one of the most exciting elections Lake City had
ever had. 25. Eluding the Police Bob and I
had a close call with the St. Louis police in the fall of that year. The
bank at Huntington, West Virginia, was robbed the first of September that
year, and in the chase of the robbers Thompson McDaniels, who had fought
with us in the war, was shot and fatally hurt. In his delirium he called
for “Bud,” and many, among whom was Detective Ely of Louisville, thought that
he meant me, I having been known familiarly throughout the war as “Bud”
Younger. This fact has made careless writers connect Brother Bob with some
of my exploits, and in his case it served to throw suspicion on me when in
fact it was probably “Bud” or Bill McDaniels, Thompson's brother, about
whom he was raving. Bill was killed shortly before, escaping from arrest
for complicity in the Muncie train
robbery. Shortly
after this Huntington affair Bob and I were coming north from Florida. We
had ridden as far as Nashville, and sold our horses there, carrying the
saddle pockets with us. Shortly before we reached St. Louis we met the
morning papers, full of the Huntington robbery, and the statement that the
robbers Were headed for Missouri. Knowing that we would be watched for in
St. Louis, I told Bob we would have to go through anyway. There were some
farmers' families on the train from White county, Tennessee, who were
moving to the big bend of the Arkansas river, the men and goods having
gone on ahead by freight. We
determined to get in with these people and bluff it through. As they
always do at St. Louis when on the lookout, a lot of detectives boarded
the train at East St. Louis and came through, but I was busy showing one
of the small boys the river, and Bob had a little girl who was equally
interested in the strange city before her. Gathering up a lot of the
baggage of the women folks, we went through the union depot. Chief of
Detectives McDonough was standing by the gate and I saw him as I passed
within a few feet of him, but he made no sign. We took the women down town
to the office where they got their rebates on their tickets, and then we
took them back to the depot and left them, very grateful for our
considerate attention, although, perhaps, we were under as deep
obligations to them as they were to us, if they had known all the
facts. But I was
determined to take no further chances, and told Bob to get in a hack that
stood outside, and if we were stopped I would get on top and drive. As we
told the driver to go to a certain hotel we allayed the suspicion of a
policeman who stood near and he made no effort to molest us. When we got
around a corner and out of sight we paid the hackman and skipped out to
Union, where we spent the night, and came up to Little Blue, on the
Missouri Pacific, the next day. 26. Ben Butler's Money There was
no change in the situation in Missouri so far as the Younger brothers were
concerned. Every daylight robbery in any part of the country, from the
Alleghenies to the Rockies, was laid at our doors; we could not go out
without a pair of pistols to protect ourselves from the attack of we knew
not whom; and finally, after one of the young ruffians who had helped in the
robbery of the Missouri Pacific express car at Otterville “confessed” that
we were with the robbers we decided to make one haul, and with our share
of the proceeds start life anew in Cuba, South America, or
Australia. Gen.
Benjamin F. Butler, whom we preferred to call “Silver Spoons” Butler from
his New Orleans experiences during the war, had a lot of money invested,
we were told, in the First National bank at Northfield, Minnesota, as also
had J. T. Ames, Butler's son-in-law, who had been the “carpet-bag”
governor of Mississippi after the war. Butler's
treatment of the Southerners during the war was not such as to commend him
to our regard, and we felt little compunction, under the circumstances,
about raiding him or his. Accordingly, about the middle of August we made
up a party to visit Northfield, going north by rail. There were Jim, Bob
and myself, Clell Miller, who had been accused of the Gad's Hill, Muncie,
Corydon, Hot Springs and perhaps other bank and train robberies, but who
had not been convicted of any of them; Bill Chadwell, a young fellow from
Illinois, and three men whose names on the expedition were Pitts, Woods
and Howard. We spent a week in Minneapolis, seeing the sights,
playing poker and looking around for information, after which we spent a
similar period in St. Paul. I was
accounted a fairly good poker player in those days, and had won about
$3,000 the winter I was in Florida, while Chadwell was one of the best
that ever played the game. We both played our last game of poker in St.
Paul that week, for he was soon to die at Northfield, and in the quarter of a
century that has passed since such a change has come over me that I not
only have no desire to play cards, but it disgusts me even to see boys
gamble with dice for cigars. This last
game was at a gambling house on East Third street, between Jackson and
Robert streets, about half a block from the Merchants' hotel, where we
were stopping. Guy Salisbury, who has since become a minister, was the
proprietor of the gambling house, and Charles Hickson was the bartender.
It was upstairs over a restaurant run by Archie McLeod, who is still in St.
Paul. Chadwell and I were nearly $300 ahead of the game when Bob came
along and insisted on sitting in, and we left the table. I never would
play in a game where Bob was. Early in
the last week in August we started on the
preliminary work for the Northfield
expedition. 27. Horace Greeley Perry When we split up in St. Paul Howard, Woods, Jim
and Clell Miller were to go to Red Wing to get their horses, while
Chadwell, Pitts, Bob and myself were to go to St. Peter or Mankato, but
Bob and Chadwell missed the train and they had me in a stew to know what
had happened to them. We watched the papers, but could find nothing about
any arrest, and Pitts and I bought our horses at St. Peter. I was known as
King, and some of the fellows called me Congressman King, insisting that I
bore some resemblance to Congressman William S. King of Minneapolis. I
bought two horses, one from a man named Hodge and the other
from a man named French, and while we were breaking them there at St.
Peter I made the acquaintance of a little girl who was afterward one of
the most earnest workers for our parole. A little
tot then, she said she could ride a horse, too, and reaching down I lifted
her up before me, and we rode up and down. I asked her name and she said
it was “Horace Greeley Perry,” and I replied: “No wonder you're such a
little tot, with such a great name.” “I won't always be little,” she replied. “I'm going to be a
great big girl, and be a newspaper man like my
pa.” “Will you still be my sweetheart then, and be my friend?” I
asked her, and she declared she would, a promise I was to remind her of
years later under circumstances of which I did not dream
then. Many years
afterward with a party of visitors to the prison came a girl, perhaps
sixteen, who registered in full “Horace Greeley
Perry.” I knew
there could not be two women with such a name in the world, and I reminded
her of her promise, a promise which she did not remember, although she had
been told how she had made friends with the bold bad man who afterwards
robbed the bank at Northfield. Very soon
afterward, at the age of eighteen, I believe, she became, as she had
dreamed in childhood, a “newspaper man,” editing the St. Peter Journal,
and to the hour of my pardon she was one of the most indefatigable workers
for us. A few years
ago failing health compelled her removal from Minnesota to Idaho, and
Minnesota lost one of the brightest newspaper writers and one of the best
and truest women and staunchest friends that a man ever knew. Jim and I
had a host of earnest advocates during the latter years of our
imprisonment, but none exceeded in devotion the young woman who, as a
little tot, had ridden, unknowingly, with the bandit who was so soon to be
exiled for life from all his kin and
friends. 28. The Northfield Raid While Pitts
and I were waiting for Bob and Chadwell we scouted about, going to Madelia
and as far as the eastern part of Cottonwood county, to familiarize
ourselves with the country. Finally, a few days later, the boys joined us,
having bought their horses at Mankato. We then
divided into two parties and started for Northfield by somewhat different
routes. Monday night, Sept. 4, our party were at Le Sueur Center, and
court being in session, we had to sleep on the floor. The hotel was full
of lawyers, and they, with the judge and other court attendants, had a
high old time that night. Tuesday night we were at Cordova, a little village in Le
Sueur county, and Wednesday night in Millersburg, eleven miles west of
Northfield. Bob and his party were then at Cannon City, to the south of
Northfield. We reunited Thursday morning, Sept. 7, a little outside
Northfield, west of the Cannon river. We took a
trip into town that forenoon, and I looked over the bank. We had dinner at
various places and then returned to the camp. While we were planning the
raid it was intended that I should be one of the party to go into the
bank. I urged on the boys that whatever happened we should not shoot any
one. “What if they begin shooting at us?” someone
suggested. “Well,” said Bob, “if Cap is so particular about the shooting,
suppose we let him stay outside and take his chances.”
So at the
last minute our plans were changed, and when we started for town Bob,
Pitts and Howard went in front, the plan being for them to await us in the
square and enter the bank when the second detachment came up with them.
Miller and I went second to stand guard at the bank, while the rest of the
party were to wait at the bridge for the signal—a pistol shot—in the event
they were needed. There were no saddle horses in evidence, and we
calculated that we would have a considerable advantage. Wrecking the
telegraph office as we left, we would get a good start, and by night would
be safe beyond Shieldsville, and the next day could ride south across the Iowa line and be
in comparative safety. But between
the time we broke camp and the time they reached the bridge the three who
went ahead drank a quart of whisky, and there was the initial blunder at
Northfield. I never knew Bob to drink before, and I did not know he was
drinking that day till after it was all
over. When Miller
and I crossed the bridge the three were on some dry goods boxes at the
corner near the bank, and as soon as they saw us went right into the bank,
instead of waiting for us to get there. When we
came up I told Miller to shut the bank door, which they had left open in
their hurry. I dismounted in the street, pretending to tighten my saddle
girth. J. S. Allen, whose hardware store was near, tried to go into the
bank, but Miller ordered him away, and he ran around the corner,
shouting: “Get your guns, boys; they're robbing the
bank.” Dr. H. M.
Wheeler, who had been standing on the east side of Division street, near
the Dampier house, shouted “Robbery! Robbery!” and I called to him to get
inside, at the same time firing a pistol shot in the air as a signal to
the three boys at the bridge that we had been discovered. Almost at this
instant I heard a pistol shot in the bank. Chadwell, Woods and Jim rode up
and joined us, shouting to people in the street to get inside, and firing
their pistols to emphasize their commands. I do not believe they killed
anyone, however. I have always believed that the man Nicholas Gustavson,
who was shot in the street, and who, it
was said, did not go inside because he did not understand English,
was hit by a glancing shot from Manning's or Wheeler's rifle. If any of
our party shot him it must have been
Woods. A man named
Elias Stacy, armed with a shot-gun, fired at Miller just as he was
mounting his horse, filling Clell's face full of bird shot. Manning took a
shot at Pitts' horse, killing it, which crippled us badly. Meantime the
street was getting uncomfortably hot. Every time I saw any one with a bead on me I
would drop off my horse and try to drive the shooter inside, but I could
not see in every direction. I called to the boys in the bank to come out,
for I could not imagine what was keeping them so long. With his second
shot Manning wounded me in the thigh, and with his third he shot Chadwell
through the heart. Bill fell from the saddle dead. Dr. Wheeler, who had
gone upstairs in the hotel, shot Miller, and he lay dying in the
street. At last the
boys who had been in the bank came out. Bob ran down the street toward
Manning, who hurried into Lee & Hitchcock's store, hoping in that way
to get a shot at Bob from behind. Bob, however, did not see Wheeler, who
was upstairs in the hotel behind him, and Wheeler's third shot shattered
Bob's right elbow as he stood beneath the stairs. Changing his pistol
to his left hand, Bob ran out and mounted Miller's mare. Howard and Pitts
had at last come out of the bank. Miller was lying in the street, but we
thought him still alive. I told Pitts to put him up with me, and I would
pack him out, but when we lifted him I saw he was dead, and I told Pitts
to lay him down again. Pitts' horse had been killed, and I told him I
would hold the crowd back while he got out on foot. I stayed there
pointing my pistol at any one who showed his head until Pitts had gone
perhaps 30 or 40 yards, and then, putting spurs to my horse, I galloped to
where he was and took him up behind me. “What kept you so long?” I asked
Pitts. Then he
told me they had been drinking and had made a botch of it inside the bank.
Instead of carrying out the plan originally formed, seizing the cashier at
his window and getting to the safe without interruption, they leaped right
over the counter and scared Heywood at the very start. As to the rest of
the affair inside the bank I take the account of a Northfield
narrator: “With a flourish of his revolver one of the robbers pointed to
Joseph L. Heywood, head bookkeeper, who was acting as cashier in the
absence of that official, and asked:” “ ‘Are you the cashier?’ ” “ ‘No,’ ” replied Heywood, and the same question was put to A.
E. Bunker, teller, and Frank J. Wilcox, assistant bookkeeper, each of whom
made the same reply. “ ‘You are the cashier,’ said the robber, turning upon Heywood,
who was sitting at the cashier's desk. ‘Open that safe—quick or I'll blow
your head off.’ ” “Pitts then ran to the vault and stepped inside, whereupon
Heywood followed him and tried to shut him in.” “One of the robbers seized
him and said:” “ ‘Open that safe now or you haven't but a minute to live.’
” “ ‘There's a time lock on,’ Heywood answered, ‘and it can't be
opened now.’ ” Howard drew
a knife from his pocket and made a feint to cut Heywood's throat, as he
lay on the floor where he had been thrown in the scuffle, and Pitts told
me afterward that Howard fired a pistol near Heywood's head to scare
him. Bunker
tried to get a pistol that lay near him, but Pitts saw his movement and
beat him to it. It was found on Charley when he was killed, so much more
evidence to identify us as the men who were in
Northfield. “Where's the money outside the safe?” Bob
asked. Bunker
showed him a box of small change on the counter, and while Bob was putting
the money in a grainsack Bunker took advantage of the opportunity to dash
out of the rear window. The shutters were closed, and this caused Bunker
an instant's delay that was almost fatal. Pitts chased him with a bullet.
The first one missed him, but the second went through his right
shoulder. As the men
left the bank Heywood clambered to his feet and Pitts, in his liquor, shot
him through the head, inflicting the wound that killed him. We had no time
to wreck the telegraph office, and the alarm was soon sent throughout the
country. Gov. John
S. Pillsbury first offered $1,000 reward for the arrest of the six who had
escaped, and this he changed afterward to $1,000 for each of them, dead or
alive. The Northfield bank offered $700 and the Winona & St. Peter
railroad $500. 29. A Chase to the Death A little
way out of Northfield we met a farmer and borrowed one of his horses for
Pitts to ride. We passed Dundas on the run, before the news of the robbery
had reached there, and at Millersburg, too, we were in advance of the
news, but at Shieldsville we were behind it. Here a squad of men, who, we
afterwards learned, were from Faribault, had left their guns outside a house. We
did not permit them to get their weapons until we had watered our horses
and got a fresh start. They overtook us about four miles west of
Shieldsville, and shots were exchanged without effect on either side. A
spent bullet did hit me on the “crazy bone,”
and as I was leading Bob's horse it caused a little excitement for
a minute, but that was all. We were in
a strange country. On the prairie our maps were all right, but when we got
into the big woods and among the lakes we were practically lost. There
were a thousand men on our trail, and watching for us at fords and bridges
where it was thought we would be apt to go. That night it started to rain,
and we wore out our horses. Friday we moved toward Waterville, and Friday
night we camped between Elysian and German lake. Saturday morning we left our
horses and started through on foot, hiding that day on an island in a
swamp. That night we tramped all night and we spent Sunday about four
miles south of Marysburg. Meantime our pursuers were watching for
horsemen, not finding our abandoned horses, it seems, until Monday or
Tuesday. Bob's
shattered elbow was requiring frequent attention, and that night we made
only nine miles, and Monday, Monday night and Tuesday we spent in a
deserted farm-house close to Mankato. That day a
man named Dunning discovered us and we took him prisoner. Some of the boys
wanted to kill him, on the theory that “dead men tell no tales,” while
others urged binding him and leaving him in the woods. Finally we
administered to him an oath not to betray our whereabouts until we had
time to make our escape, and he agreed not to. No sooner, however, was he
released than he made posthaste into Mankato to announce our presence, and
in a few minutes another posse was looking for us.
Suspecting,
however, that he would do so, we were soon on the move, and that night we
evaded the guard at the Blue Earth river bridge, and about midnight made
our way through Mankato. The whistle
on the oil mill blew, and we feared that it was a signal that had been
agreed upon to alarm the town in case we were observed, but we were not
molested. Howard and Woods, who had favored killing Dunning, and who felt
we were losing valuable time because of Bob's wound, left us that night
and went west. As we afterward learned, this was an advantage to us as
well as to them, for they stole two horses soon after leaving us, and the
posse followed the trail of these horses, not knowing that our party had been
divided.
Accordingly, we were not pursued, having kept on a course toward
Madelia to a farm where I knew there were some good horses, once in
possession of which we could get along
faster. We had been
living on scant rations, corn, watermelon and other vegetables
principally, but in spite of this Bob's arm was mending somewhat. He had
to sleep with it pillowed on my breast, Jim being also crippled with a
wound in his shoulder, and we could not get much sleep. The wound in my
thigh was troubling me and I had to walk with a cane I cut in the brush.
One place we got a chicken and cooked it, only to be interrupted before we
could have our feast, having to make a quick dash for
cover. At every
stopping place we left marks of blood from our wounds, and could have been
easily trailed had not the pursuers been led in the track of our recent
companions. It seems
from what I have read since, however, that I had myself left with my
landlord at Madelia, Col. Vought, of the Flanders house, a damaging
suggestion which proved the ultimate undoing of our party. I had talked
with him about a bridge between two lakes near there, and accordingly when
it became known that the robbers had passed Mankato Vought thought of this
bridge, and it was guarded by him and others for two nights. When they
abandoned the guard, however, he admonished a Norwegian boy named Oscar
Suborn to keep close watch there for us, and Thursday morning, Sept. 21,
just two weeks after the robbery, Oscar saw us, and fled into town with
the alarm. A party of
forty was soon out in search for us, headed by Capt. W. W. Murphy, Col.
Vought and Sheriff Glispin. They came up with us as we were fording a
small slough, and unable to ford it with their horses, they were delayed
somewhat by having to go around it. But they soon after got close enough
so that one of them broke my walking stick with a shot. We were in sight of
our long-sought horses when they cut us off from the animals, and our last
hope was gone. We were at bay on the open prairie, surrounded by a picket
line of forty men, some of whom would fight. Not prepared to stand for our
last fight against such odds on the open field, we fell back into the
Watonwan river bottoms and took refuge in some
bushes. We were
prepared to wait as long as they would, but they were not of the waiting
kind. At least some of them were not, and soon we heard the captain, who,
we afterward learned, was W. W. Murphy, calling for volunteers to go in
with him and rout us out. Six stepped to the front, Sheriff Glispin, Col.
T. L. Vought, B. M. Rice, G. A. Bradford, C. A. Pomeroy and S. J.
Severson. Forming in
line four paces apart, he ordered them to advance rapidly and concentrate
the fire of the whole line the instant the robbers were
discovered. Meanwhile we were planning, too.
“Pitts,” I said, “if you want to go out and surrender, go
on.” “I'll not go,” he
replied, game to the last. “I can die as well as you
can.” “Make for the horses,” I said. “Every man for himself. There is
no use stopping to pick up a comrade here, for we can't get him through
the line. Just charge them and make it if we can.”
I got up as
the signal for the charge and we fired one volley. I tried to get my man,
and started through, but the next I knew I was lying on the ground,
bleeding from my nose and mouth, and Bob was standing up,
shouting: “Coward!” One of the
fellows in the outer line, not brave enough himself to join the volunteers
who had come in to beat us out, was not disposed to believe in the
surrender, and had his gun levelled on Bob in spite of the handkerchief
which was waving as a flag of truce. Sheriff
Glispin, of Watonwan county, who was taking Bob's pistol from him, was
also shouting to the fellow: “Don't shoot him or I'll shoot
you.” All of us
but Bob had gone down at the first fire. Pitts, shot through the heart,
lay dead. Jim, including the wound in the shoulder he received at
Northfield, had been shot five times, the most serious being the shot
which shattered his upper jaw and lay imbedded beneath the brain, and a
shot that buried itself underneath his spine, and which gave him trouble
to the day of his death. Including those received in and on the way from
Northfield I had eleven wounds. A bullet
had pierced Bob's right lung, but he was the only one left on his feet.
His right arm useless, and his pistol empty, he had no
choice. “I surrender,” he had shouted. “They're all down but me. Come
on. I'll not shoot.” And Sheriff
Glispin's order not to shoot was the beginning of the protectorate that
Minnesota people established over us. We were
taken into Madelia that day and our wounds dressed, and I greeted my old
landlord, Col. Vought, who had been one of the seven to go in to get us.
We were taken to his hotel and a guard
posted. Then came
the talk of mob vengeance we had heard so often in Missouri. It was said a
mob would be out that night to lynch us. Sheriff Glispin swore we would
never be mobbed as long as we were his
prisoners. “I don't want any man to risk his life for us,” I said to
him, “but if they do come for us give us our pistols so we can make
a fight for it.” “If they do come, and I weaken,” he said, “you can have your
pistols.” But the only mob that came was the mob of sightseers, reporters
and detectives. 30. To Prison for Life Saturday we
were taken to Faribault, the county seat of Rice county, in which
Northfield is, and here there was more talk of lynching, but Sheriff Ara
Barton was not of that kind either, and we were guarded by militia until
the excitement had subsided. A Faribault policeman, who thought the
militia guard was a bluff, bet five dollars he could go right up to the jail without being
interfered with. He did not halt when challenged, and was fired upon and
killed, the coroner's jury acquitting the militiaman who shot him. Some
people blamed us for his death, too. Chief of
Detectives McDonough, of St. Louis, whom I had passed a few months before
in the union depot at St. Louis, was among our visitors at
Faribault. Another was
Detective Bligh, of Louisville, who believed then, and probably did ever
afterward, that I had been in the Huntington, West Virginia, robbery, and
tried to pump me about it. Four
indictments were found against us. One charged us with being accessory to
the murder of Cashier Heywood, another with assaulting Bunker with intent
to do great bodily harm, and the third with robbing the First National
bank of Northfield. The fourth charged me as principal and my brothers as
accessories with the murder of Gustavson. Two witnesses had testified
before the grand jury identifying me as the man who fired the shot that
hit him, although I know I did not, because I fired no shot in that part
of town. Although
not one of us had fired the shot that killed either Heywood or Gustavson,
our attorneys, Thomas Rutledge of Madelia and Bachelder and Buckham of
Faribault, asked, when we were arraigned, Nov. 9, that we be given two
days in which to plead. They advised us that as accessories were equally
guilty with the principals, under the law, and as by pleading guilty we
could escape capital punishment, we should plead guilty. There was
little doubt, under the circumstances, of our conviction, and under the
law as it stood then, an accused murderer who pleaded guilty was not
subject to the death penalty. The state was new, and the law had been made
to offer an inducement to murderers not to put the county to the expense of a trial.
The
excitement that followed our sentence to state prison, which was popularly
called “cheating the gallows,” resulted in the change of the law in that
respect. The
following Saturday we pleaded guilty, and Judge Lord sentenced us to
imprisonment for the remainder of our lives in the state prison at
Stillwater, and a few days later we were taken there by Sheriff
Barton. With Bob it
was a life sentence, for he died there of consumption Sept. 16, 1889. He
was never strong physically after the shot pierced his lung in the last
fight near Madelia. 31. Some Private History Every blood-and-thunder history of the Younger
brothers declares that Frank and Jesse James were the two members of the
band that entered Northfield who escaped arrest or death.
They were
not, however. One of those two men was killed afterward in Arizona and the
other died from fever some years
afterward. There were
reasons why the James and the Younger brothers could not take part in any
such project as that at Northfield. Frank James and I came together as
soldiers some little time before the Lawrence raid. He was a good soldier,
and while he never was higher than a private the distinctions between the
officers and the men were not as finely drawn in Quantrell's command as
they are nowadays in military life. As far back as 1862, Frank James and I
formed a friendship, which has existed to this
day. Jesse James
I never met, as I have already related, until the early summer of 1866.
The fact that all of us were liable to the visits of posses when least
expected gave us one interest in common, the only one we ever did have,
although we were thrown together more or less through my friendship with Frank
James. The
beginning of my trouble with Jesse came in 1872, when George W. Shepherd
returned to Lee's Summit after serving a term in prison in Kentucky for
the bank robbery at Russellville in 1868. Jesse had told me that Shepherd
was gunning for me, and accordingly one night, when Shepherd came late to
the home of Silas Hudspeth, where I was, I was prepared for trouble, as in
fact, I always was anyway. When Shepherd called, Hudspeth shut the door
again, and told me who was outside. I said “let him in,” and stepping to
the door with my pistol in my hand, I said: “Shepherd, I am in here;
you're not afraid, are you?” “That's all right,” he answered. “Of course I'm not afraid.”
The three of us talked till bedtime, when Hudspeth told us to occupy the
same bed. I climbed in behind, and as was my custom, took my pistol to bed
with me. Shepherd says he did not sleep a wink that night, but I did. At
breakfast next morning, I said: “I heard yesterday that you intended to kill me on sight; have
you lost your nerve?” “Who told you that, Cole?” he
answered. “I met Jess yesterday and he told me that you sent that message
to me by him.” Soon after
I met Jesse James, and but for the interference of friends we would have
shot it out then and there. My feeling toward Jesse became more bitter in
the latter part of that year, when after the gate robbery at the Kansas
City fair, he wrote a letter to the Times of that city declaring that he
and I had been accused of the robbery, but that he could prove an alibi.
So far as I know that is the first time my name was ever mentioned in
connection with the Kansas City robbery. In 1874,
when Detective Whicher was killed on a trip to arrest Frank and Jesse
James, I was angered to think that Jesse and his friends had brought
Whicher from Kearney to the south side of the river, which I then believed
was done to throw suspicion on the boys in Jackson county, of whom,
perhaps, I would be most likely to get the credit. I have since learned, however,
from the men who did kill Whicher, that Jesse did not kill him, but had
believed his story and had been inclined to welcome him as a fellow
wanderer. Whicher declared that he had murdered his wife and children in
the East and he was seeking a refuge from the officers of the law. But Jesse's comrades were skeptical,
and when they found on Whicher a pistol bearing Pinkerton's mark, they
started with him for Kansas City intending to leave him dead in the street
there. Shortly after they crossed to the Independence side of the river,
the sound of a wagon on the frozen ground impelled them to finish the job
where they were, as it was almost daybreak and they did not want to be seen with their captive.
But Jesse and I were not on friendly terms at any time after the Shepherd
affair, and never were associated in any
enterprises. 32. Lost—Twenty-five Years When the
iron doors shut behind us at the Stillwater prison I submitted to the
prison discipline with the same unquestioning obedience that I had exacted
during my military service, and Jim and Bob, I think, did the same. For
ten years and a half after our arrival, Warden Reed remained. The first
three years there was a popular idea that such desperate men as the
Youngers would not stay long behind prison walls, and that especial
watchfulness must be exercised in our case. Accordingly the three of us
were put at work making buckets and tubs, with Ben Cayou over us as a
special guard, when in our dreams we had been traveling to South America
on Ben Butler's money. Then we
were put in the thresher factory. I made the sieves, while Jim sewed the
belts, and Bob made the straw-carriers and elevators. The latter part of
the Reed regime I was in the storeroom. Jan. 25, 1884, when we had been in
the prison something over seven years, the main prison building was
destroyed by fire at night. George P. Dodd, who was then connected with
the prison, while his wife was matron, and who still lives in Buffalo,
Minn., said of our behavior that night: “I was obliged to take the female convicts from their cells and
place them in a small room that could not be locked. The Youngers were
passing and Cole asked if they could be of any service. I said: ‘Yes,
Cole. Will you three boys take care of Mrs. Dodd and the women?’ Cole
answered: ‘Yes, we will, and if you ever had any confidence in us place it
in us now.’ I told him I had the utmost confidence and I slipped a pistol
to Cole as I had two. Jim, I think, had an ax handle and Bob a little
pinch bar. The boys stood before the door of the little room for hours and
even took the blankets they had brought with them from their cells
and gave them to the women to try and keep them comfortable as it was very
cold. When I could take charge of the women and the boys were relieved,
Cole returned my revolver.” Next
morning Warden Reed was flooded with telegrams and newspaper sensations:
“Keep close watch of the Youngers;” “Did the Youngers escape?” “Plot to
free the Youngers,” and that sort of
thing. The warden
came to his chief deputy, Abe Hall, and suggested that we be put in irons,
not that he had any fear on our account, but for the effect on the
public. “I'll not put irons on 'em,” replied Hall. And that day Hall
and Judge Butts took us in a sleigh down town to the county jail where we
remained three or four weeks. That was the only time we were outside the prison enclosure
from 1876 till 1901. When H. G.
Stordock became warden, I was made librarian, while Jim carried the mail
and Bob was clerk to the steward where we remained during the
administration of Wardens Randall and Garvin, except Bob, who wasted away
from consumption and died in September,
1889. When Warden
Wolfer came to the prison, he put Jim in charge of the mail and the
library, and I was set at work in the laundry temporarily while the new
hospital building was being made ready. I was then made head nurse in the
hospital, and remained there until the day we were paroled, Warden Reeve, who
was there for two years under the administration of Gov. Lind, leaving us
there. Every one
of these wardens was our friend, and the deputy wardens, too. Abe Hall,
Will Reed, A. D. Westby, Sam A. Langum, T. W. Alexander, and Jack Glennon
were all partisans of ours. If any reader misses one name from this list
of deputy wardens, there is nothing I have to say for or against him. Dr.
Pratt, who was prison physician when we went to Stillwater, Dr. T. C.
Clark, who was his assistant, and Dr. B. J. Merrill, who has been prison
physician since, have been staunch partisans of the Younger boys in the
efforts of our friends to secure our pardon. And the young doctors with whom I was thrown in close
contact during their service as assistant prison physicians, Drs. Sidney
Boleyn, Gustavus A. Newman, Dan Beebe, A. E. Hedbeck, Morrill Withrow, and
Jenner Chance, have been most earnest in their championship of our
cause. The
stewards, too, Benner, and during the Reeve regime, Smithton, which whom
as head nurse I was thrown in direct contact, never had any difficulty
with me, although Benner with a twinkle in his eye, would say to me:
“Cole, I believe you come and get peaches for your patients up
there long after they are dead.” The
invalids in that hospital always got the delicacies they wanted, subject
to the physician's permission, if what they wanted was to be found
anywhere in Stillwater or in St. Paul. The prison hospital building is not
suitable for such use, and a new hospital building is needed, but no fault
can be found with the way invalid prisoners are cared for at Stillwater.
When there
is added a new hospital building, and the present hospital is transformed
into an insane ward, Stillwater will indeed be a model
prison. Words fail me when I seek to express my gratitude to the host
of friends who were glad to plead our cause during the later years of our
confinement at Stillwater, and especially to Warden Henry Wolfer and his
family, every one of whom was a true friend to Jim and
myself. 33. The Star of Hope In spite of
the popular indignation our crime had justly caused, from the day the iron
gates closed behind us in 1876, there were always friends who hoped and
planned for our ultimate release. Some of these were misguided, and did us
more harm than good. Among these were two former guerrillas, who committed
small crimes that they might be sent to prison and there plot with us for
our escape. One of them was only sent to the county jail, and the other
served a year in Stillwater prison without ever seeing
us. Well
meaning, too, but unfortunate, was the declaration of Missouri friends in
Minnesota that they could raise $100,000 to get us out of Stillwater. But
as the years went by, the popular feeling against us not only subsided,
but our absolute submission to the minutest details of prison discipline
won for us the consideration, I might even say the high esteem of the
prison officials who came in contact with us, and as the Northfield
tragedy became more and more remote, those who favored our pardon became
more numerous, and yearly numbered in their ranks more and more of the
influential people of the state, who believed that our crime had been
avenged, and that Jim and I, the only survivors of the
tragedy, would be worthy citizens if restored to freedom. My Missouri
friends are surprised to find that I prize friendships in Minnesota, a
state where I found so much trouble, but in spite of Northfield, and all
its tragic memories, I have in Minnesota some of the best friends a man ever had on
earth. Every
governor of Minnesota from as early as 1889 down to 1899 was petitioned
for our pardon, but not one of them was satisfied of the advisability of a
full pardon, and the parole system provided by the enlightened
humanitarianism of the state for other convicts did not apply to
lifers. Under this
system a convict whose prison record is good may be paroled on his good
behavior after serving half of the term for which he was
sentenced. The
reiterated requests for our pardon, coming from men the governors had
confidence in, urging them to a pardon they were reluctant to grant, led
to a feeling, which found expression finally in official circles, that the
responsibility of the pardoning power should be divided by the creation of
a board of pardons as existed in some other
states. It was at
first proposed that the board should consist of the governor, attorney
general and the warden of the prison, but before the bill passed, Senator
Allen J. Greer secured the substitution for the chief justice for the
warden, boasting, when the amendment was made: “That ties the Youngers up for as long as Chief Justice Start
lives.” A unanimous
vote of the board was required to grant a pardon, and as Chief Justice
Start had lived in the vicinity of Northfield at the time of the raid in
1876, many people believed that he would never consent to our
pardon. In the
legislature of 1889, our friends endeavored to have the parole system
extended to life prisoners, and secured the introduction in the
legislature of a bill to provide that life prisoners might be paroled when
they had served such a period as would have entitled them to their release
had they been sentenced to imprisonment for 35 years. The bill was drawn by George M.
Bennett of Minneapolis, who had taken a great deal of interest in our
case, and was introduced in the senate by Senator George P. Wilson, of
Minneapolis. As the good time allowances on a 35-year sentence would cut
it to between 23 and 24 years, we could have been paroled in a few months
had this bill passed. Although there was one other inmate of the prison
who might have come under its provisions, it was generally known as the
“Youngers' parole bill” and the feeling against it was largely identified
with the feeling against us. I am told, however, since my release, that it
would have passed at that session had it
not been for the cry of “money” that was used. There never was a
dollar used in Minnesota to secure our pardon, and before our release we
had some of the best men and women in the state working in our behalf,
without money and without price. But this outcry defeated the bill of
1899. Still it
did not discourage our friends on the outside. At the next session of the
legislature, 1901, there was finally passed the bill which permitted our
conditional parole, the pardon board not being ready to grant us our full
freedom. This bill provided for the parole of any life convict who had
been confined for twenty years, on the unanimous consent of the board of
pardons. The bill
was introduced in the house by Representative P. C. Deming of Minneapolis,
and among those who worked for its passage was Representative Jay W.
Phillips, who, as a boy, had been driven from the streets the day we
entered Northfield. Senator Wilson, who had introduced the bill which
failed in 1899, was again a staunch supporter and led the fight for us in
the senate. The board of prison managers promptly granted the
parole the principal conditions of which were as follows:
“He shall not exhibit himself in any dime museum, circus
theater, opera house, or any other place of public amusement or assembly
where a charge is made for admission.” “He shall on the twentieth day of each month write the warden
of the state prison a report of himself, stating whether he had been
constantly at work during the last month, and if not, why not; how much he
has earned, and how much he has expended, together with a general
statement as to his surroundings and prospects, which must be indorsed by his employer.” “He shall in all respects conduct himself honestly, avoid evil
associations, obey the law, and abstain from the use of intoxicating
liquors.” “He shall not go outside the state of
Minnesota.” The parole was unanimously concurred in by Messrs. B. F.
Nelson, F. W. Temple, A. C. Weiss, E. W. Wing, and R. H. Bronson, of the
prison board and urged by Warden Henry
Wolfer. The board
of pardons, in indorsing our parole, said: “We are satisfied that the
petitioners in this case have by exceptionally good conduct in prison for
a quarter of a century, and the evidence they have given of sincere
reformation, earned the right to a parole, if any life prisoner can do
so.” And July
14, 1901, Jim and I went out into the world for the first time in within a
few months of twenty-five years. Rip Van Winkle himself was not so long
away. St. Paul and Minneapolis which, when we were there in 1876, had less
than 75,000 people all told, had grown to cities within whose limits
were over 350,000. A dozen railroads ended in one or the other of these
centers of business that we had known as little better than frontier
towns. 34. On Parole Our first
positions after our release from prison were in the employ of the P. N.
Peterson Granite company, of St. Paul and Stillwater, Mr. Peterson having
known us since early in our prison life. We were to
receive $60 a month each and expenses. Jim was to take care of some office
work, and take orders in the immediate vicinity of Stillwater. He worked
mostly through Washington county, and with a horse and buggy, but had not
been at work more than two months when the sudden starting of the horse
as he was getting out of the buggy started anew his intermittent
trouble with the bullet that lodged under his spine, and he was compelled
to find other employment. He then
went into the cigar department of the Andrew Schoch grocery company in St.
Paul, and after several months there was employed by Maj. Elwin, of the
Elwin cigar company in Minneapolis, where he remained until a few days
before his death. I traveled
for the Peterson company until Nov., 1901, covering nearly all of
Minnesota. But the change from the regularity of prison hours to the
irregular hours, meals and various changes to which the drummer is subject
was too much for me, and I returned to St. Paul to enter the employ of
Edward J. and Hubert C. Schurmeier, who had been strenuous workers for my pardon,
and James Nugent at the Interstate institute for the cure of the liquor
and morphine habits, on Rosabel street in St. Paul. There I remained
several months, and then was employed by John J. O'Connor, chief of police
at St. Paul, in connection with private interests to which he could not give his personal
attention. 35. Jim Gives It Up The bullet
wound which Jim received in our last fight near Madelia, shattering his
upper jaw, and remaining imbedded near his brain, until it was removed by
Dr. T. G. Clark after we were in the prison at Stillwater, affected Jim at
intervals during all his prison life, and he would have periodical spells
of depression, during which he would give up all hope, and his gloomy spirits
would repel the sympathy of those who were disposed to cheer him
up. I remember
that at the time of the fire in 1884, he was in one of these fits of
depression, but the excitement of that time buoyed him up, and he was
himself again for a considerable period. After our
release from prison, Jim's precarious health and his inability to rejoin
his family in Missouri combined to make these fits of depression more
frequent. While he was working for Maj. Elwin, instead of putting in his
afternoons, which were free, among men, or enjoying the sunshine and air
which had so long been out of our reach, he would go to his room and revel
in socialistic literature, which only tended to overload a mind already
surcharged with troubles. For my part, I tried to get into the world
again, to live down the past, and I could and did enjoy
the theaters, although Jim declared he would never set foot in
one until he could go a free man. In July, he and some of his friends
petitioned the board of pardons for a full pardon, but the board was of
the opinion that it was too early to consider that, believing that we
should be kept on our good behavior for a
time. That
resulted in another fit of depression for Jim. He took it to heart, and
never regained his cheerful mood, for when he was up, he was away up, and
when down, away down. There was no half way place with
Jim. In October,
1902, he left Maj. Elwin expecting to go to St. Paul to work for Yerxa
Bros. But Sunday
afternoon, Oct. 19, his dead body was found in a room at the hotel
Reardon, Seventh and Minnesota streets, St. Paul, where he had been
staying since leaving Minneapolis. His trunk had been sent to friends, and
there was every indication that he had carefully planned his death by his
own hand. A bullet hole above his right ear and a pistol clutched in his hand,
told the story of suicide. Dr. J. M. Finnell, who as acting coroner, was
summoned, decided that he must have shot himself early in the forenoon,
although neighbors in the block had not been disturbed by the
shot. I was sick
in bed at the time and my physician, Dr. J. J. Platt, forbade my
attempting to do anything in the premises, but Jim's body was taken in
charge in my behalf by Chief of Police O'Connor, and borne to Lee's
Summit, Mo., our old Jackson county home, where it was laid to
rest. The
pallbearers were G. W. Wigginton, O. H. Lewis, H. H. McDowell, Sim Whitsett, William Gregg and William
Lewis, all old neighbors or comrades during the war. Some people obtained
the idea that it was Jim's wish that he be cremated, but this idea grew
out of a letter he left showing his gloomy condition. It “roasted” Gov.
Van Sant and Warden Wolfer and the board of pardons, declared for
socialism, and urged Bryan to come out for
it. On the
outside of the envelope was written: “All relations stay away from me. No crocodile tears wanted.
Reporters, be my friends. Burn me up.—Jim
Younger.” I think the
“burn me up” was an admonition to the reporters. Jim always felt that the
papers had been bitter to us, although some of them had been staunch
supporters of the proposal for our parole. The day we were paroled, Jim
said to a visiting newspaper woman: “When we get out
we would like to be left in peace. We don't want to be stared at and we
don't want to be interviewed. For twenty-five years now, we have been
summoned here to have men stare at us and question us and then go back and
write up what they think and believe. It's hard to have people write
things about you that are not true and put words in your mouth that you
never uttered.” It was to such newspaper men, I think, that Jim sent his
message “Burn me up.” 36. Free Again Jim's
tragic death brought the Youngers again into the public eye, and aside
from any effort on my part, there was a renewed discussion of the
advisability of extending a full pardon to me, the lone survivor of the
band who had invaded Northfield. At the next
quarterly meeting of the board, which was held in January of this year,
the matter was taken up, and the board considered my application, which
was for an absolute or a conditional pardon as the board might see
fit. It was
urged on my behalf that the limitation clause confining me to Minnesota
was one that it might be well to do away with, as it prevented me from
joining my friends and relatives in Missouri, and kept me in a state,
where a great many people did not really care for my society, although so
many were very kind and cordial to me. Against
this it was urged that while I was in the state, the board could exercise
a supervision of my employment and movements which it might be judicious
to continue. After
carefully considering the various arguments for and against my absolute
pardon, the board decided against it, but at a special meeting held
February 4, 1903, voted unanimously for a conditional pardon as
follows: “Having carefully considered this matter, with a keen
appreciation of our duty to the public and to the petitioner, we have
reached the conclusion that his conduct for twenty-five years in prison,
and his subsequent conduct as a paroled prisoner, justify the belief that
if his request to be permitted to return to his friends and kindred be
granted, he will live and remain at liberty without any violation of the
law.” “We are, however, of the opinion that his
absolute pardon would not be compatible with the welfare of this state—the
scene of his crime—for the reason that his presence therein, if freed from
the conditions of his parole, would create a morbid and demoralizing
interest in him and his crime.” “Therefore it is ordered that a pardon be granted to Thomas
Coleman Younger, upon the condition precedent and subsequent that he
return without unnecessary delay to his friends and kindred whence he
came, and that he never voluntarily come back to
Minnesota.” “And upon the further condition that he file with the governor
of the State of Minnesota his written promise that he will never exhibit
himself or allow himself to be exhibited, as an actor or participant in
any public performance, museum, circus, theater, opera house or any other
place of public amusement or assembly where a charge is made for admission; Provided, that this shall
not exclude him from attending any such public performance or place of
amusement.” “If he violates any of the conditions of this pardon, it shall
be absolutely void.” S. R. Van Sant, Governor. Chas. M. Start, Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court Wallace B. Douglas,
Attorney-General. A few days
later I filed with Governor Van Sant the following:
“I, Thomas Coleman Younger, pursuant to one of the conditions
upon which a pardon has been granted to me, do hereby promise upon my
honor that I will never exhibit myself, nor allow myself to be exhibited,
as an actor or participant in any public performance, museum, circus,
theater, opera house, or any place of public amusement or assembly where a charge is made for
admission.” 37. The Wild West The “Cole
Younger and Frank James' Historical Wild West Show” is an effort on the
part of two men whose exploits have been more wildly exaggerated, perhaps,
than those of any other men living, to make an honest living and
demonstrate to the people of America that they are not as black as they
have been painted. There will
be nothing in the Wild West show to which any exception can be taken, and
it is my purpose, as a part owner in the show, and I have put in the
contracts with my partners, that no crookedness nor rowdyism will be
permitted by attaches of the I show. We will assist the local authorities,
too, in ridding the show of the sort of camp-followers who frequently make
traveling shows the scapegoat for their misdoings. We propose to have our
show efficiently and honestly policed, to give the people the worth of
their money, and to give an entertainment that will show the frontiersman
of my early manhood as he was. I had hoped
if my pardon had been made unconditional, to earn a livelihood on the
lecture platform. I had prepared a lecture which I do think would not have
harmed any one, while it might have impressed a valuable lesson on those
who took it to heart. I give it herewith under the title, “What My Life
Has Taught Me.” 38. What My Life Has Taught Me Looking
back through the dimly lighted corridors of the past, down the long vista
of time, a time when I feared not the face of mortal man, nor battalions of
men, when backed by my old comrades in arms, it may seem inconsistent to
say that I appear before you with a timidity born of cowardice, but
perhaps you will understand better than I can tell you that twenty-five
years in a prison cell fetters a man's intellect as well as his
body. Therefore I
disclaim any pretensions to literary merit, and trust that my sincerity of
purpose will compensate for my lack of eloquence; and, too, I am not so
sure that I care for that kind of oratory that leaves the points to guess
at, but rather the simple language of the soul that needs no
interpreter. Let me say,
ladies and gentlemen, that the farthest thought from my mind is that of
posing as a character. I do not desire to stand upon the basis of the
notoriety which the past record of my life may have earned for
me. Those of
you who have been drawn here by mere curiosity to see a character or a
man, who by the events of his life has gained somewhat of notoriety, will
miss the real object of this lecture and the occasion which brings us
together. My soul's desire is to benefit you by recounting some of the
important lessons which my life has taught me. Life is too
short to make any other use of it. Besides, I owe too much to my fellow
men, to my opportunities, to my country, to my God and to myself, to make
any other use of the present occasion. Since I am
to speak to you of some of the important lessons of my life, it may be in
order to give you some account of my ancestry. It is something to one's
credit to have had an ancestry that one need not be ashamed of. One of the
poets said, while talking to a select party of aristocracy: Depend upon
it, my snobbish friend, Your family line you can't ascend Without good reason to
apprehend. You'll find it waxed at the farther end With some plebeian
vocation; Or, what is worse, your family line May end in a loop of
stronger twine That plagued some worthy
relation. But I am
proud to say, ladies and gentlemen, that no loop of stronger twine that he
referred to ever plagued any relation of mine. No member of our family or
ancestry was ever punished for any crime or infringement of the law. My
father was a direct descendant from the Lees on one side and the Youngers
on the other. The Lees came from Scotland tracing their line back to
Bruce. The Youngers were from the city of Strasburg on the Rhine,
descending from the ruling family of Strasburg when that was a free
city. My sainted
mother was a direct descendant from the Sullivans, Ladens and Percivals of
South Carolina, the Taylors of Virginia, and the Fristoes of Tennessee.
Richard Fristoe, mother's father, was one of three judges appointed by the
governor of Missouri to organize Jackson county, and was then elected one
of the first members of the legislature. Jackson county was so named in
honor of his old general, Andrew Jackson, with whom he served
at the battle of New Orleans. My father
and mother were married at Independence, the county seat of Jackson
county, and there they spent many happy years, and there my own happy
childhood days were spent. There were fourteen children of us; I was the
seventh. There were seven younger than myself. How often in the dark days
of the journey over the sea of life have I called up the happy
surroundings of my early days when I had a noble father and dear mother to appeal
to in faith for counsel. There had never been a death in the family up to
1860, except among our plantation negroes. Mine was a happy
childhood. I do not
desire to pose as an instructor for other people, yet one man's experience
may be of value to another, and it may not be presumptuous for me to tell
some of the results of experience, a teacher whose lessons are severe,
but, at least, worthy of consideration. I might say, perhaps, with
Shakespeare, “I have bought golden opinions from all sorts of
people.” The subject
of my discourse tonight is the index of what is to follow. I believe that
no living man can speak upon his theme with more familiarity. I have lived
the gentleman, the soldier, the out-law, and the convict, living the best
twenty-five years of my life in a felon's cell. I have no desire to pose
as a martyr, for men who sin must suffer, but I will punctuate my remarks
with bold statements, for the eagle should not be afraid of the storm. It
is said that there are but three ways by which we arrive at knowledge in
this world; by instruction, by observation, and by experience. We must learn our lessons in life by some one or
all of these methods. Those of us who do not, or will not, learn by
instruction or by observation are necessarily limited to the fruits of
experience. The boy who is told by his mother that fire burns and who has
seen his brother badly burned, surely does not need to have the fact still
more clearly impressed upon his mind by experience. Yet in the majority of
cases, it takes experience to satisfy him. By a kind of necessity which I
cannot at this point stop to explain, I have had to learn some very
impressive lessons of my life by the stern teacher, experience. Some
people express a desire to live life over again, under the impression that
they could make a better success of it on a second trip; such people
are scarcely logical—however sincere they may be in a wish of this kind.
They seem to forget that by the unfailing law of cause and effect, were
they to go back on the trail to the point from which they started and try
it over again, under the same circumstances they would land about where
they are now. The same causes would produce the same effect. I confess
that I have no inexpressible yearnings to try my life over again, even if
it were possible to do so. I have followed the trail of my life for
something over fifty years. It has led me into varied and strange
experiences. The last
twenty-six years, by a train of circumstances I was not able to control,
brought me to the present place and hour. Perhaps it may be proper for me
to say, with St. Peter, on the mount of transfiguration, it is good to be
here. The man who chooses the career of outlawry is either a natural fool
or an innocent madman. The term outlaw has a varied meaning. A man may be
an outlaw, and yet a patriot. There is the outlaw with a heart of velvet
and a hand of steel; there is the outlaw who never molested the sacred sanctity of any man's
home; there is the outlaw who never dethroned a woman's honor, or assailed
her heritage; and there is the outlaw who has never robbed the honest
poor. Have you heard of the outlaw who, in the far-off Western land, where
the sun dips to the horizon in infinite beauty, was the adopted son of the Kootenai Indians?
It was one of the saddest scenes in all the annals of human
tragedy. It was
during one of those fierce conflicts which characterized earlier frontier
days. The white outlaw had influenced the red man to send a message of
peace to the whites, and for this important mission the little son of the
Kootenai chief was selected. The young fawn mounted his horse, but before
the passport of peace was delivered the brave little courier was shot to
pieces by a cavalcade of armed men who slew him before questioning his mission. The little boy
was being stripped of the adornments peculiar to Indians when the outlaw
rode upon the scene. “Take your hands off him, or by the God, I'll cut them off,” he
shouted. “You have killed a lone child—the messenger of peace—peace which
I risked my life to secure for the white men who outlawed
me.” Taking the
dead body tenderly in his arms, he rode back to face the fury of a wronged
people. He understood the penalty but went to offer himself as a ransom,
and was shot to death. This,
however, is not the class of outlaws I would discuss, for very often force
of circumstances makes outlaws of men, but I would speak of the criminal
outlaw whom I would spare not nor excuse.
My friends,
civilization may be a thin veneer, and the world today may be slimy with
hypocrisy, but no man is justified in killing lions to feed dogs. Outlawry
is often a fit companion for treason and anarchy, for which the lowest
seats of hell should be reserved. The outlaw, like the commercial
freebooter, is often a deformity on the face of nature that darkens the
light of God's day. I need not explain my career as an outlaw, a career
that has been gorgeously colored with fiction. To me the word outlaw is a
living coal of fire. The past is a tragedy—a tragedy wherein danger lurks
in every trail. I may be pardoned for hurrying over a few wild, relentless years that led up to a career of
outlawry—a memory that cuts like the sword blades of a squadron of
cavalry. The outlaw
is like a big black bird, from which every passerby feels licensed to
pluck a handful of feathers. My young
friend, if you are endowed with physical strength, valor, and a steady
hand, let me warn you to use them well, for the God who gave them is the
final victor. Think of a
man born of splendid parents, good surroundings, the best of advantages, a
fair intellectuality, with the possibility of being president of the
United States, and with courage of a field general. Think of him lying
stagnant in a prison cell. This does not apply alone to the highway
outlaw, but to those outlaws who are sometimes called by the softer name “financier.” Not
long ago I heard a man speak of a certain banker, and I was reminded that
prisons do not contain all the bad men. He said: “Every dog that dies has
some friend to shed a tear, but when that man dies there will be universal
rejoicing.” I am not
exactly a lead man, but it may surprise you to know that I have been shot
between twenty and thirty times and am now carrying over a dozen bullets
which have never been extracted. How proud I should have been had I been
scarred battling for the honor and glory of my country. Those wounds I
received while wearing the gray, I've ever been proud of, and my regret is
that I did not receive the rest of them during the war with Spain, for the
freedom of Cuba and the honor and glory of this great and glorious
republic. But, alas, they were not, and it is a memory embalmed that nails
a man to the cross. I was in
prison when the war with Cuba was inaugurated, a war that will never pass
from memory while hearts beat responsive to the glory of battle in the
cause of humanity. How men turned from the path of peace, and seizing the
sword, followed the flag! As the blue ranks of American soldiery scaled
the heights of heroism, and the smoke rose from the hot altars of the
battle gods and freedom's wrongs avenged, so the memory of Cuba's
independence will go down in history, glorious as our own revolution—'76
and '98—twin jewels set in the crown of sister centuries. Spain and the world have learned that beneath
the folds of our nation's flag there lurks a power as irresistible as the
wrath of God. Sleep on,
side by side in the dim vaults of eternity, Manila Bay and Bunker Hill,
Lexington and Santiago, Ticonderoga and San Juan, glorious rounds in
Columbia's ladder of fame, growing colossal as the ages roll. Yes, I was
in prison than, and let me tell you, dear friends, I do not hesitate to
say that God permits few men to suffer as I did, when I awoke to the full
realization that I was wearing the stripes instead of a uniform of my
country. Remember,
friends, I do not uphold war for commercial pillage. War is a terrible
thing, and leads men sometimes out of the common avenues of life. Without
reference to myself, men of this land, let me tell you emphatically, is passionately, and absolutely
that war makes savages of men, and dethrones them from reason. It is too
often sugarcoated with the word “patriotism”
to make it bearable and men call it “National honor.”
Come with
me to the prison, where for a quarter of a century I have occupied a
lonely cell. When the door swings in on you there, the world does not hear
your muffled wail. There is little to inspire mirth in prison. For a man
who has lived close to the heart of nature, in the forest, in the saddle,
to imprison him is like caging a wild bird. And yet imprisonment has
brought out the excellencies of many men. I have learned many things in
the lonely hours there. I have learned that hope is a divinity; I have
learned that a surplus of determination conquers every weakness; I have
learned that you cannot mate a white dove to a
blackbird; I have learned that vengeance is for God and not for man; I
have learned that there are some things better than a picture on a church
window; I have learned that the American people, and especially the good
people of Minnesota, do not strip a fallen foe; I have learned that
whoever says “there is no God” is a fool;
I have learned that politics is often mere traffic, and
statesmanship trickery; I have learned that the honor of the republic is
put upon the plains and battled for; I have learned that the English
language is too often used to deceive the commonwealth of labor; I have
learned that the man who prides himself on getting on the wrong side of
every public issue is as pernicious an enemy to the country as the man who openly fires upon the flag; and I have
seen mute sufferings of men in prison which no human pen can
portray. And I have
seen men die there. During my twenty-five years of imprisonment, I have
spent a large portion of the time in the hospital, nursing the sick and
soothing the dying. Oh! the sadness, the despair, the volcano of human woe
that lurks in such an hour. One, a soldier from the North, I met in battle
when I wore the gray. In '63 I had led him to safety beyond the
Confederate lines in Missouri, and in '97 he died in my arms in the
Minnesota prison, a few moments before a full pardon had arrived from the
president. The details of this remarkable coincidence were pathetic in the
extreme, equalled only by the death of my young brother Bob.
And yet, my
dear friends, prisons and prison discipline, which sometimes destroy the
reason, and perpetuate a stigma upon those who survive them,—these, I say,
are the safeguards of the nation. A man has
plenty of time to think in prison, and I might add that it is an ideal
place for a man to study law, religion, and Shakespeare, not forgetting
the president's messages. However, I would advise you not to try to get
into prison just to find an ideal place for these particular studies. I
find, after careful study, that law is simply an interpretation of the Ten Commandments,
nothing more, nothing less. All law is founded upon Scripture, and
Scripture, in form of religion or law, rules the universe. The infidel who
ridicules religion is forced to respect the law, which in reality is
religion itself. It is not
sufficient alone to make good and just laws, but our people must be
educated, or should be, from the cradle up, to respect the law. This is
one great lesson to be impressed upon the American people. Let the world
know that we are a law-loving nation, for our law is our
life. Experience
has taught me that there is no true liberty apart from law. Law is a
boundary line, a wall of protection, circumscribing the field in which
liberty may have her freest exercise. Beyond the boundary line, freedom
must surrender her rights, and change her name to “penalty for
transgression.” The law is no enemy, but the friend of liberty. The world
and the planets move by law. Disregarding the law by which they move, they
would become wanderers in the bleak darkness
forever. The human
mind in its normal condition moves and works by law. When self-will,
blinded by passion or lust, enters her realm, and breaks her protecting
laws, mind then loses her sweet liberty of action, and becomes a
transgressor. Chaos usurps the throne of liberty, and mind becomes at
enmity with law. How many, many times the words of the poet have sung to my soul during
the past twenty-six years: Eternal spirit of the chainless
mind, Brightest in dungeon's liberty thou
art, For there thy habitation is the
heart, The heart, which love of thee alone can
bind. Your
locomotive with her following load of life and treasure is safe while she
keeps the rails, but, suppose that with an insane desire for a larger
liberty, she left the rails and struck out for herself a new pathway,
ruin, chaos and death would strew her course. And again let me impress the
fact upon you. Law is one of humanity's valiant friends. It is the safeguard of the
highest personal and national liberties. The French revolution furnishes a
standing illustration of society without
law. There are
times when I think the American people are not patriotic enough. Some
think patriotism is necessary only in time of war, but I say to you it is
more necessary in time of peace. When the safety of the country is
threatened, and the flag insulted, we are urged on by national pride to
repel the enemy, but in time of peace selfish interests take the greater
hold of us, and retard us in our duty to
country. Nowhere is
patriotism needed more than at the ballot-box. There the two great
contestants are country and self, and unless the spirit of patriotism
guides the vote our country is sure to lose. To be faithful citizens we
must be honest in our politics. The political star which guides us should
be love for our country and our country's laws. Patriotism,
side by side with Christianity, I would have to go down to future
generations, for wherever the church is destroyed you are making room for
asylums and prisons. With the martyred Garfield, I, too, believe that our
great national danger is not from
without. It may be
presumptuous in me to proffer so many suggestions to you who have been
living in a world from which I have been exiled for twenty-five years. I
may have formed a wrong conception of some things, but you will be
charitable enough to forgive my errors. I hope to
be of some assistance to mankind and will dedicate my future life to
unmask every wrong in my power and aid civilization to rise against
further persecution. I want to be the drum-major of a peace brigade, who
would rather have the good will of his fellow creatures than shoulder
straps from any corporate power. One of the
lessons impressed upon me by my life experience is the power of that which
we call personal influence, the power of one mind or character over
another. Society is an aggregate of units. The units are related. No one
lives or acts alone, independently of another. Personal influence plays
its part in the relations we sustain to each
other. Do you ask
me to define what I mean by personal influence? It is the sum total of
what a man is, and its effect upon another. Some one has said, “Every man
is what God made him,” and some are considerably more so. That which we
call character is the sum total of all his tendencies, habits, appetite
and passions. The terms
character and reputation are too often confused. Character is what you
really are; reputation is what some one else would have
you. Every man
has something of good in him. Probably none of us can say that we are all
goodness. I have
noticed that when a man claims to be all goodness, that claim alone does
not make his credit any better in business, or at the bank. If a man is
good, the world has a way of finding out his qualities. Most men are
willing to admit, at least to themselves, that their qualities are
somewhat mixed. I do not believe that the good people of the world are all bunched up in one corner and
the bad ones in another. Christ's parable of the wheat and the tares
explains that to my satisfaction. There is goodness in all men, and
sermons even in stones. But goodness and badness is apt to run in streaks.
Man, to use the language of another, is a queer combination of cheek and
perversity, insolence, pride, impudence, vanity, jealousy, hate, scorn,
baseness, insanity, honor, truth, wisdom, virtue and urbanity. He's a
queer combination all right. And those mixed elements of his nature, in
their effects on other people, we call personal influence. Many a man is
not altogether what he has made himself, but what others have made him.
But a man's personal influence is within his own
control. It is at the gateway of his nature from which his
influence goes forth that he needs to post his sentinels. Mind stands
related to mind, somewhat in the relation of cause and
effect. Emerson
said, “You send your boy to school to be educated, but the education that
he gets is largely from the other boys.” It is a kind of education that he
will remember longer and have a greater influence upon his character and
career in life than the instructions he gets from the
teacher. The great
scholar, Elihu Burritt, has said, “No human being can come into this world
without increasing or diminishing the sum total of human happiness.” No
one can detach himself from the connection. There is no spot in the
universe to which he can retreat from his relations to
others. This makes
living and acting among our fellows a serious business. It makes life a
stage, ourselves the actors—some of us being remarkably bad actors—and
imposes upon us the obligation to act well our part. Therein all honor
lies. And in order to do this it behooves us to stock up with the
qualities of mind and character, the influence of which will be helpful to those who
follow the trail behind us. Another
plain duty my experience has pointed out is that each of us owes an
honest, manly effort toward the material world's progress. Honest labor is
the key that unlocks the door of happiness. One of the silliest notions
that a young man can get into his head is the idea that the world owes him
a living. It does not owe you the fraction of a red cent, young man. What have you
done for the world that put it under obligation to you? When did the world
become indebted to you? Who cared for you in the years of helpless
infancy? Who built the schoolhouse where you got the rudiments of your
education? The world was made and equipped for men to develop it. Almighty
God furnished the world well. He provided abundant coal beds, oceans of
oil, boundless forests, seas of salt. He has ribbed the mountain with gems
fit to deck the brows of science, eloquence and art. He has furnished
earth to produce for all the requirements of man.
He has provided man himself with an intellect to fathom and
develop the mysteries of His handiwork. Now He commands that mortal man
shall do the rest, and what a generous command it is! And this is the
world that owes you a living, is it? This
reminds me of a man who built and thoroughly equipped a beautiful church,
and presented it as a gift to the congregation. After expressing their
gratitude, a leading member of the church said to the generous donor: “And
now may we request that you put a lightning-rod on the church to secure it
against lightning?” The giver
replied: “No. I have built a church wherein to worship Almighty God, and
if He sees fit to destroy it by lightning, let Him
strike.” There was a
church struck by lightning in New Jersey, where the big trust magnates met
for worship, and the Lord is excused for visiting it with lightning. No,
the Lord is not going to strike down your good works at all. He has laid
out an earthly Paradise for each of us, and nothing is due us except what
we earn by honest toil and noble endeavor. We owe the world a debt of
gratitude we can never repay for making this a convenient dwelling-place.
We owe the world the best there is in us for its development. Gerald
Massey put it right when he said: “Toil is creation's crown, worship is
duty.” Another
important lesson life has taught me is the value, the priceless value, of
good friends, and with Shakespeare I say: “Grapple them to thy soul with
hooks of steel.” Some sage has said: “A man is known by the company he can
not get into.” But truly this would be a barren world without the
association of friends. But a man must make himself worthy of friends, for
the text teaches us that “A man who wants friends must show himself
friendly.” What I am today, or strive to be, I owe largely to my
friends—friends to whom I fail in language to express
my gratitude, which is deeper than the lips; friends who led us to
believe that “stone walls do not a prison make, nor iron bars a cage;”
friends who understand that human nature and sincerity are often clothed
in prison garb; friends who have decreed that one false step does not lame
a man for life. Oh, what a
generous doctrine! And, although unwritten, I believe God has set his seal
upon it. Honest friendship is a grand religion, and if we are true to
ourselves, the poet tells us, we cannot be false to any
man. However, I
am forced to admit that there are many brands of friendship existing these
days which had not birth in our time. For instance: A number of men have
visited me in the prison, and assured me of their interest in a pardon,
etc. They have talked so eloquently and earnestly that I thought I was
fortunate to enlist the sympathies and aid of such splendid men. After the first or
second visit I was informed as gently as possible that a price was
attached to this friendship; how much would I give them for indorsing or
signing a petition for a pardon? I remember how I glared at them, how my
pulse almost ceased beating, at such demands. What injustice to the public to petition a man out of
prison for a price! If a man can not come out of prison on his merits, let
him remain there. I hold, too, that if there is honor among thieves there
should be among politicians and pretentious citizens. I hate a liar and a
false man. I hate a hypocrite, a man whose word to his friend is not as good as gold.
My friends,
there is just one thing I will say in my own defense if you will so far
indulge me. I do not believe in doing under the cover of darkness that
which will not bear the light of day. During my career of outlawing I rode
into town under the glare of the noonday sun, and all men knew my mission.
Corporations of every color had just cause to despise me then. But no man
can accuse me of prowling about at night, nor of ever having robbed an
individual, or the honest poor. In our time a man's word was equal to his
oath, and seldom did a man break faith when he had once pledged himself to
another. What I say
to you, fellow citizens, I say not in idle boast, but from the soul of a
man who reverences truth in all its simplicity. Think of it—a price for a
man's proffered friendship. On my soul, I do not even now comprehend so
monstrous a proposition, and, believe me, even the unfortunate creatures
about me in prison looked more like men than your respectable citizens and
professional men with a price for their
friendship. I should
like to say something to the ladies who have honored me with their
presence. But as I have been a bachelor all my life I scarcely know what
to say. I do know, though, that they are the divine creatures of a divine
Creator; I do know that they are the high priestesses of this land; and,
too, I say, God could not be everywhere, so He made woman. One almost needs the lantern of a
Diogenes in this progressive age to find an honest man, but not so with a
good woman, who is an illumination in herself, the light of her influence
shining with a radiance of its own. You will agree with me that the
following lines contain more truth than poetry, and I bow to the splendid
genius of the author: Blame woman not if some
appear too cold at times, and some too gay and light; Some griefs gnaw
deep—some woes are hard to bear. Who knows the past, and who can judge
them right? Perhaps you have heard of banquets “for gentlemen
only.” Well, it was upon one of these occasions that one of the guests was
called upon to respond to a toast—“The
Ladies.” There being
no ladies present, he felt safe in his remarks. “I do not believe,” he
said, “that there are any real, true women living any more.” The guest
opposite him sprang to his feet and shouted: “I hope that the speaker
refers only to his own female relations.” I never could understand,
either, when a man goes wrong it is called “misfortune,” while if a woman goes wrong it
is called “shame.” But I presume, being in prison twenty-five years, I am
naturally dull, and should not question a world I have not lived in for a
quarter of a century. I tell you, my friends, that I know very little of
women, but of one thing I am morally certain: If the front seats of
Paradise are not reserved for women, I am willing to take a back seat with
them. It seems to me that every man who had a mother should have a proper
regard for womanhood. My own mother was a combination of all the
best elements of the high character that belong to true wife
and motherhood. Her devotion and friendship were as eternal as the very
stars of heaven, and no misfortune could dwarf her generous impulses or
curdle the milk of human kindness in her good
heart. Her memory
has been an altar, a guiding star, a divinity, in the darkest hour when
regrets were my constant companions. It is true that I was a mere boy, in
my teens, when the war was on, but there is no excuse for neglecting a
good mother's counsel, and no good can possibly result. I was taught that
honor among men and charity in the errors of others were the chief duties
of mankind, the fundamentals of law, both human and divine. In those two
commandments I have not failed, but in other respects I fell short of my
home influence, and so, my young friends, do not do as I have done, but do
as I tell you to do—honor the fourth
commandment. There is no
heroism in outlawry, and the fate of each outlaw in his turn should be an
everlasting lesson to the young of the land. And even as Benedict Arnold,
the patriot and traitor, dying in an ugly garret in a foreign land, cried
with his last breath to the lone priest beside him: “Wrap my body in the
American flag;” so the outlaw, from his inner soul, if not from his lips,
cries out, “Oh, God, turn back the
universe!” There is
another subject I want to say a word about—one which I never publicly
advocated while in prison, for the reason that I feared the outside world
would believe it a disguise to obtain my freedom. Freedom is the
birthright heritage of every man, and it was very dear to me, but if the
price of it was to pretend to be religious, the price was too high, and I
would rather have remained in prison. Some men in prison fly to it as a
refuge in sincerity—some otherwise. But to the sincere it is a great
consolation, for it teaches men that hope is a divinity,
without which no man can live and retain his
reason. But now
that I have been restored to citizenship I feel free to express my views
upon religion without fear that men will accuse me of hypocrisy. I do not
see why that word “hypocrisy” was ever put in the English language. Now, I
am a lecturer, not a minister, but I want to say that I think it is a wise
plan to let the Lord have his own way with you. That's logic. The man who
walks with God is in good company. Get into partnership with Him, but
don't try to be the leading member of the firm. He knows more about the
business than you do. You may be able for a time to practice deception
upon your fellow men, but don't try to fire any blank cartridges at the
Author of this Universe. There are a
great many ways to inspire a man with true Christian sentiment, and I must
say that the least of them is sitting down and quoting a text from
Scripture. Religious men and women have visited me in prison who have
never mentioned religion, but have had the strongest influence over me.
Their sincerity and conduct appealed to one more strongly than the bare Scripture.
I can see
in imagination now one whom I have so often seen in reality while in
prison. She was a true, sweet, lovely, Christian young lady. I remember
once asking her if all the people of her church were as good as she was.
She replied, honestly and straightforwardly: “No; you will not find them
all so liberal toward their unfortunate brothers, and every church has its
share of hypocrites—mine the same as others. But God and the church remain
just the same.” There are some don'ts I would call to your attention. One
of them is, don't try to get rich too quickly by grasping every bait
thrown out to the unwary. I have been in the society of the fellows who tried to get rich quickly for the
past twenty-five years, and for the most part they are a poor lot. I do
not know but that I would reverse Milton's lines so as to read: 'Tis
better to sit with a fool in Paradise Than some of those wise ones in
prison. Don't resort to idleness. The boy who wears out the seat of his
trousers holding down dry-goods boxes on the street corners will
never be president of the United States. The farmer who drives
to town for pleasure several days in the week will soon have his farm
advertised for sale. An idle man is sure to go into the hands of a
receiver. My friends, glorious opportunities are before us, with
the republic's free institutions at your command. Science and knowledge
have unlocked their vaults wherein poverty and wealth are not classified—a
fitting theater where the master mind shall play the leading
role. And now,
with your permission, I will close with a bit of verse from Reno, the
famous poet-scout. His lines are the embodiment of human nature as it
should be, and to me they are a sort of creed. He
says: "I never like to see a man a-wrestling with the
dumps, 'Cause in the game of life he doesn't always catch the
trumps, But I can always cotton to a free-and-easy
cuss As takes his dose and thanks the Lord it wasn't any
wuss. There ain't no use of swearin' and cussin' at your
luck, 'Cause you can't correct your troubles more than you can drown
a duck. Remember that when beneath the load your suffering head is
bowed That God will sprinkle sunshine in the trail of every
cloud. If you should see a fellow man with trouble's flag
unfurled, And lookin' like he didn't have a friend in all the
world, Go up and slap him on the back and holler, “How'd you
do?” And grasp his hand so warm he'll know he has a friend in
you, An' ask him what's a-hurtin' him, and laugh his cares
away, An' tell him that the darkest hour is just before the
day. Don't talk in graveyard palaver, but say it right out
loud, That God will sprinkle sunshine in the trail of every
cloud. This world at best is but a hash of pleasures and of
pain; Some days are bright and sunny, and some are sloshed with
rain; An' that's jes' how it ought to be, so when the clouds roll
by We'll know jes' how to 'preciate the bright and smilin'
sky. So learn to take things as they come, and don't sweat at the
pores Because the Lord's opinion doesn't coincide with
yours; But always keep rememberin', when cares your path
enshroud, That God has lots of sunshine to spill behind the
cloud." An Afterward Since the foregoing was written I find that the publication of
libels on myself and my dead brothers continues. The New York publishers
of “five-cent-dreadfuls” are the worst offenders.
One of them
has published two books since my release from prison, in one of which my
brothers and I are accused of the M., K. & T. train robbery at Big
Springs, and in the other of the Chicago & Alton robbery at the
Missouri Pacific crossing near Independence,
Mo. We had been
in Stillwater prison nearly a year when the Big Springs robbery was
committed, it being in September, 1877. I forget the date of the Alton
robbery, but that branch of the Alton was not built until after we were
sent to Stillwater, so we can not be reasonably accused of
that. For the
portraits of my old guerrilla comrades, of whom authentic likenesses are,
at this late day, hard to find, I am especially indebted to Mr. Albert
Winner, of Kansas City, whose valuable collection of war pictures was
kindly placed at my disposal. COLE YOUNGER
|
|