Solomon Prentice  1731 - 1749
Aaron Hutchinson  1750 - 1772
Daniel Grosvenor  1774 - 1788
John Miles   1796 - 1826
Moses C. Searle  1826 - 1832
John Wilde   1831 - 1838
Thomas C. Biscoe  1839 - 1868
John H. Windsor  1868 - 1883
Benjamin A. Robie  1884 - 1900
Samuel Allen Harlow  1901 - 1917
Philip King   1918 - 1922
John T. Stewart  1923 - 1926
Herbert Edwin Lombard 1926 - 1929
Roger Peake Cleveland 1929 - 1949
Stephen W. Turrell  1949 - 1958
John Filler   1959 - 1963
David E. Wilson III  1963 - 1969
John W. Wilson  1969 - 1974
John Cedarleaf  1975 - 1985
Timothy E. Hanley  1985 - 1992
Duane R. Brown  1994 -

Associate Pastors

Kathryn J. Timpany  1988 - 1989
Christy Parks-Ramage  1990 - 1994
 

     ......information gathered by Amy Brown